By David Black

Alfred Sohn-Rethel positioned the beginning of philosophical abstraction within the "false conciousness" caused through the hot cash financial system of Greek Antiquity. within the Enlightenment the conceptual barrier Kant positioned among exceptional truth and the "thing-in-itself" expressed, in Sohn-Rethel's view, the reified cognizance stemming from commodity-exchange and the department of psychological and guide hard work. simply because Sohn-Rethel observed the full heritage of philosophy as branded through a undying common good judgment, he disregarded Hegel's inspiration of "totality" as "idealist" and Hegel's critique of Kantian dualism as inappropriate to Marx's critique of political economy.

David Black, within the name essay of The Philosophical Roots of Anti-Capitalism, indicates, contra Sohn-Rethel, that Marx's exposition of the fetishism of commodities is historically-specific to capitalist construction, and as a result can't clarify the origins of philosophy, which Black indicates to have concerned quite a few old advancements in Greek society and tradition in addition to monetization. simply as Hegel's critique of Kantian formalism informs Marx's critique of capital, Hegel's writings on how the right kind association of work could abolish the barrier Aristotle positioned among construction and the "Realm of Freedom" prefigure Marx's efforts to formulate of a substitute for capitalism.

Part Two, Critique of the Situationist Dialectic: paintings, classification awareness and Reification, starts with Surrealism, whose "disappearance" as a innovative inventive and social strength man Debord and the Situationists sought to make up for by way of superseding the poetry of paintings with the poetry of existence. to boot highlighting Debord's achievements in either idea and perform, Black issues to his philosophical shortcomings and relates those to Debord's later "pessimistic" evaluate of the potential of progressive type awareness inside globalizing capitalism.

The 4 essays in Part Three disguise the Aristotelian anarchism, the ambivalent legacy of Lukács' idea of reification, Raya Dunayevskaya's Hegelian-Marxist idea of "absolute negativity" as "revolution in permanance", and Gillian Rose's philosophical problem to either postmodernism and "traditional" Marxism.

Show description

Read or Download The Philosophical Roots of Anti-Capitalism: Essays on History, Culture, and Dialectical Thought PDF

Similar capitalism books

Global History: A View from the South

Responding to the necessity to take a clean examine global heritage, hitherto ruled by means of Eurocentric ideologues and historians of their try to justify the character and personality of recent capitalism, Samir Amin appears during this publication on the old international method and the way it has motivated the improvement of the fashionable global.

Political Economy and Global Capitalism: The 21st Century, Present and Future

Robert Albritton, Bob Jessop, Richard Westra (eds. )

This quantity brings jointly unique and well timed writings through the world over well known students that consider the present trajectories of worldwide capitalism and, within the mild of those, contemplate most likely, attainable or fascinating futures. It bargains theory-informed writing that contextualizes empirical examine on present world-historic occasions and developments with a watch in the direction of understanding a way forward for human, social and financial betterment.


'This is an illuminating choice of essays on the place we're and the place we'd turn out, from a exclusive overseas and interdisciplinary crew of students and activists. ' —Stuart Elden, affiliate Director of the foreign barriers learn Unit, Durham University

The Transition from Feudalism to Capitalism

The Transition from Feudalism to Capitalism
Paul M. Sweezy and Maurice Dobb
Science & Society
Vol. 14, No. 2 (Spring, 1950) (pp. 134-167)
Page count number: 34

Of Synthetic Finance: Three Essays of Speculative Materialism

Artificial finance revolutionizes materialism such that we will now create wealth within the means of universally allotting it. whereas monetary innovation in international capitalism supplied the stipulations for the 2008 monetary hindrance, it has additionally engineered a collection of monetary applied sciences with common distributive power.

Extra info for The Philosophical Roots of Anti-Capitalism: Essays on History, Culture, and Dialectical Thought

Example text

These old principles are manifested in the equal distribution of land use and produce (Moira) and the booty of plunder. But most importantly, they are also manifested in the communality of the sacrificial feast, in which all present partake equally of the distribution of roasted meat. The sacrifices of animals are enacted in religious sanctuaries, which take in donations, not only of the animal sacrificial victims, but also of durable objects associated with the sacrifice, such as metal figurines of the animals and of the deities, iron tripod cauldrons and roasting spits.

The organization is the secret society in which admission takes place through initiation rites. For the cult of Dionysus, human existence is the cyclical life of the seasons. The conceptual framework is thus temporal, rather than spatial. The intoxicating spirit of Dionysus is human; the rituals of his thiasmos draw the god into the group or make the individuals lose themselves in the community of the divine and the One. As Cornford puts it, Orgiastic ritual ensures that Dionysus, even when his worship was contaminated with Olympian cults, never became fully an Olympian.

69 For Aristotle, the condition for happiness is the well-functioning polis, and the material principle of the polis is justice. This principle is defined as the quality and quantity of the citizens running their oikoi rather than the physical territory. The active principle of the polis is the legislator 20 Chapter 1 whose work founds the constitution and gives the polis its true form. The final purpose (telos) of the polis is self-sufficiency and the good life. 70 In Aristotle’s Politics, the women and slaves of the oikoi and the barbarians outside of the polis represent a pre-political world ruled by the “passions” which need to be subjugated by men whose “superior” nature has been demonstrated by their actual creation of the polis.

Download PDF sample

Rated 4.26 of 5 – based on 22 votes